Former Packers receivers James Jones and Greg Jennings have become frequent critics of Aaron Rodgers on FS1, representing a shift in tone from teammates who once defended him. On *Breakfast Ball*, Jones recently suggested the New York Jets should consider benching Rodgers if his performance doesn’t improve, arguing that the team has high expectations that Rodgers hasn’t yet met. While Jones has previously supported Rodgers, including during the quarterback’s contentious final years in Green Bay, this critique suggests he’s starting to evaluate Rodgers’ performance more critically, especially as the Jets struggle.
Greg Jennings, who appears on *First Things First*, has been even harsher. He frequently sides with show host Nick Wright in criticizing Rodgers, often focusing on his leadership and attitude. Jennings has spoken openly about past disagreements, calling Rodgers “selfish” for his approach to contract negotiations with the Packers. This commentary contrasts starkly with A.J. Hawk, another former teammate who often defends Rodgers on *The Pat McAfee Show*, creating a noticeable divide among former Packers in the media.
The criticism reflects a broader trend, as Rodgers has become a polarizing figure for his off-field remarks and handling of various controversies. While Jones and Jennings may be speaking candidly as analysts, their takes reveal how complex Rodgers’ legacy has become, even among former teammates. Fans seem to value this direct approach, wanting insiders to be honest rather than protective. With Rodgers facing high expectations in New York, the scrutiny from former teammates on national platforms highlights how he’s seen differently across the NFL media landscape.
